Origin of the Palestinians
Article Tools
-
37
Liked it
Subscribe to RSS
The origin of the Palestinians and the land called Israel (or Palestine as called by Romans) and who should “own” the land. A brief history look at the modern day Palestinian-Israeli conflict.
The Palestinians are the modern day descendants of two ancient civilizations – the Canaanites and the Philistines. According to early history and the Bible, the present day land was called the Land of Canaan and the Canaanites ruled the area. Their society was fragmented with a city-state-like structure where each area or city had it own king with political and religious duties. The Canaanites came to power at around 3,000 BCE but their kingdom systematically fell to invasion from ancient Israelis freed from their bondage in Egypt.
The Philistines came into the land at around 1200 BCE and mainly lived near the southern coastal plains (near present day Gaza). Both the Philistines and Canaanites were considered “pagans” by Jews, Christianities and Muslims because of their polytheistic beliefs. Later, following the arrival of the Jews, many converted to Judaism and centuries later to Christianity. The Israelis took up residence in the land at around 1000 BCE and with a fierce military conquest, established the longest lasting dynasty in the Middle East. However, the identity of the Hebrew people itself is as indigenous to the land as the identity of the Palestinians or their ancestors. At the time of around 610 AD (C.E.), almost 1600 years later, most of Palestine was either Christian or Jewish and the most widely used language was Aramaic and Hebrew. This territory remained in the lands of the Jews for the better part of the 1600 years until the Roman invasions and later the Byzantine Empire. All of this changed with the rise of Islam in 600s AD and shortly after the death of the Prophet Mohammad, the Arabs started extensive campaigns in the Middle East.
Warriors from the Arabian Peninsula swept across the Middle East and into Northern Africa and within a few short years, these lands were incorporated into their rapidly expanding Islamic empire. The conquered people were keen to embrace Islam as their religion. However, Islam did not become the religion of the majority in Palestine until around the 9th century but even today there still remains a large Christian minority among the Palestinian people (10%-15% depending on source of data). As with Islam, the language of the Arabs called Arabic soon spread and by 9th century it became the dominant language of the region. The mainstream of Palestinian society became assimilated into the Arabic and Islamic identities, thus the reason for many Palestinian’s intertwined identities.
While the Jews did not embrace Islam or the Arab culture, they actually encouraged the rule of their new Arab rulers. Their reasoning was that they would be better off ruled by Muslim Arabs than by the Roman legions or the Byzantine empires. The Muslim Arabs, at least for 2-3 centuries, considered the Jews and the Christians as the “people of the book” and accepted the divine revelations of Judaism and Christianity and thus tolerance of each other’s cultures were encouraged. However, the Jewish Diaspora never came back together as a collective and the establishment of the Jewish state was not a agenda pursued by either Muslims or the Jewish community. The notion that the Arab-Israeli conflict or the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is a millennia old blood feud is utterly wrong.
During the time of the Muslim rule, there was no Hebrew or Palestinian state. Both groups shared the land. The Jewish History and the Palestinian history are striking similar, both modern day ideologies of Zionism and Arab Nationalism came in the end of the 19th century with the involvement of the Europeans in Middle East. The land is the ancient home for both people and no one group has exclusive claim. From 1000 BCE, the Jews and the Palestinians have been living in the land (with a Jewish State existing for majority of these years) in pace. The rise in nationalism in both groups is the cause for the current modern day struggle we see in the Middle East. Recognizing that both groups have no choice but to live together, Israelis, Palestinians and other Arabs may one day choose to place emphasis on the common elements in their respective national identities instead of their differences could result in a peaceful solution to the Palestinian-Israeli-Arab conflict that is plaguing the modern age.











13 Comments
The biggest myth is that the Palestinian people are Arabs. That lie has been perpetuated by Arab leaders for their own propaganda purposes. If Arab leaders actually cared about Palestine, why don’t they give us some oil money to rebuild our land?
If Arab leaders cared about us, then why is the Egyptian border with Gaza closed? If Arabs really cared for us, then Why are my people living still as refugees in Jordan? If Arabs really cared about us, then why is Jordan refusing to allow Palestinian people become Jordanian citizens and refusing to allow the people to become residents of Jordan by leaving the refugee camps?
I agree with you Hamza 100%. The problem is that some Palestinian people and other “Arabs” agrue that the Palestinian people are Arabs and that Palestine belongs to the Arabs. However, by claiming that Palestinians are Arabs, the validity to their claim to the land is undermined. Since Arabs came to the region only through the expansion of Islam and thus Arabized the inhabitants of Palestine, claiming that they are Arabs wrongly states that they have been in Palestine since the seventh century as opposed to thousands of years before the rise of Islam. As a Palestinian, I believe that we should be proud of our non-arab lineage and make our claim to the land through the fact that we are ethnically Canaanites and Philistines and not merely Arabs. Each “Arab” group has its own distinct dialect and culture from other “Arabs” due to the fact that their culture, particularly Palestinians, is descended from their ancestors. I am writing this comment not because I despise Arabs or I feel being Palestinian is better or superior, but because I believe in Palestinians (and other Arabized groups) embracing their ancestors is historically accurate and will enable Palestinians to possess a valid claim to the land of Palestine. Salaam.
That’s not prove you claims,
Arab Palestinains are Arabs living in Palestine and they are mix of many gentiles, not only Arabs by origin. Islamization made them all to think they are one original ancient people. But its all false.
The Palestinian Arabs origin from 70 different nations stock togetehr in the same land and accepted being Muslims by belief. That’s why the Arab Christian in Palestine, as in the whole ME Islamic world, are being masacred and refuged by their Muslims “brothers”.
http://www.nrg.co.il/online/1/ART1/483/521.html
Salam Aleikum.
http://www.cdn-friends-icej.ca/isreport/hamas.html
The Hamas does not care for the people, they just want to accomplish their political goals for their for selfish gains. Their own charter tells us that plainly.
Both sides are locos!!! That’s what religion does to countries and people. Crazy people understand themselves pretty well within each other. Religoin has masacre and killed millions in the name of God in the history of the world. You guys really are showing the world the morals of being loving people. You scare many people in this world.
Hi~
I think that palestinian are a Mix of different group of populations:
1- The canaanites
2- The Philistines
3- The Hebrews
4- Ottoman
5- European croises
6- African nomades
7- Arabs
That’s the reason why, some palestinian have dark skin and some others have blond hairs. Palestinian is not an homogenous population.
I think that most of palestinian people should have hebrew bloods. Most of genetic studies could proove that palestinian DNA is closer to Jews than to arabs!
In fact many Isralies are also a mix of different ethnic groups:
1- Hebrews
2- Arabs
3-Khazar
4- African from ethipia
5- European
6- Berbers from North africa
It is intestesting to remark that Israelies Yemenite Jews DNA is closer to arabs than to jews. Morrocan Jews DNA also is closer to Berber people than to arabs or jews.
People have to live in peace together in the middle east.
Don’t forget that some members of Hamas are in fact from hebrew ancesters, and some israelis jews are in fact from arabic ancesters!
PEACE!!
Palestinians are Arabs. People in the ME who are not Arabs but islamized are Iranians (Persians). Palestinians are not Caananites or Philistines. That’s just propaganda to delegitimize the Jews’ historical claims to Israel. Next, maybe the Mohamed fellow will tell us that Jesus was a Palestinian, which is a claim even some Palestinian Christians believe.
Palestinians were simply pawns of certain foreign powers until recently when they are beginning to realize that their identity as a group of people are being eroded away.
Yes, lot of mistakes have been made on both sides of the issue. Palestinians listened to the foolish advice of their neighbors and took up violence and intolerance. But many are beginning to realize that violence and hate will not get them their own state or their own identity.
They have to be patient and undo the years of mistrust, hatred, violence and wars to regain their identity. They must be willing to live in peace with their Israeli counterparts on the same land or their dream of a statehood will never come to pass.
In the same way, Israel needs to understand the plight of the Palestinians. In some way of form, Israel must be willing to let a Palestinian state be formed. Yes, security is a concern but both sides must be willing to make amends.
Other than the Israelis and the Palestinians, the other Arab neighbors should stay out of the issue. Why? Well so far the other Arab countries have not done a single thing to fix the issue. They only inflamed the hatred and made things worse.
In countries like Lebanon and Jordan, the Palestinian refugees are still living in a refugee camp when they should have been provided with housing and better access to jobs, health care, education and less discrimination. Egypt should have opened their borders to address humanitarian issues while Saudi Arabia and the other neighbors should have made sure that extremism and violence should not have gained root in their own countries or spill over into the Palestinian society. Better yet, if the OPEC member nations set aside 1% of their profits each year and honor their promises to the Palestinian people by making monetary contribution for rebuilding, education and health care, the people would have been much better off.
So yes, this issue had a little to do with everyone and everyone can share the blame. But from now on, the Palestinian people and Israelis must work things out without the negative intervention of outside “interests” in the issue. If countries want an input, they can do so by providing monetary and other tangible aid to the Palestinian people (less speeches about the “infidels” and more action plz).
See, there, that’s my quick take on the issue. maybe i will writer another article on it later.
It is true that jews always try to demonize Palestinians from branding them all as terrorists to claiming that they have no ancestral ties to the land. jews are the true anti-semites against Palestinians. It’s stupid but Palestinian DNA is similar to jewish DNA.
I expect this to happen. It won’t be religion that ends the violence, it will be the economy and science that finally brings this issue to an end.
David is wrong. First off, any dictionary definition can tell you that an anti-Semite is racism, bigotry and/or prejudice against Jewish people. We Jews don’t “demonize” the Palestinians. Of course, there are many Palestinians who would choose a normal life instead of war with Israel. They’re not the ones who will take control of the territories if or when Israel leaves. The ones who take control are the rejectionist terrorists who seek Israel’s destruction. You claim that Palestinians are the original Jews. That claim is false. Palestinians are Arabs and are descendants of the Arabs who came to Palestine after it was conquered. Some are also descendants of Arabs who came to Palestine because of economic opportunities because the Jews were rebuilding the land. We Jews are descendants of the Israelites. Yes, the Palestinians have legitimate claims to the land. But so do the Jews. Eretz Israel is our historic homeland. For more than 3,000 years, there was a Jewish presence on the land. Rebuilding the land has been at the core of Jewish identity.
Palestinian identity lacks the philosophical dimension (The Jewish Torah). There is a Palestinian dialect, but the argumant the Arabs have many lands and Jews have only one reigns, not to say the Palestinians have no right to land.
The aagenda that all of Israel is Palestine is very problematic for the Jewish people. Many Palestinian villages carry Hebrew names from ancient times and Judaism is truly connected to this malaria stricken poeace of land. Ask any Bible student.
When is a semite not a semite? Whenever it contradicts the Zionist mythology or runs counter to the silly idea that “god” gave the Levant to the Jewish people. Palestinians are semites. The proof is in the DNA, the culture and history of the people.
Haplogroup research indicates that Palestinians are broadly descendent from the various people of the Levant such as the Canaanites, the Amarites the Amalekites, the Hittites, the Israelites, the Moabites, the Philistines, Phoenicians etc etc with some input from the various occupiers such as Egyptians, Ottomans, Assyrians, Arabs, Crusaders etc. Archeological research has indicated that the Israelites and Judahans were just one of a number of different people who lived during ancient times in the area of what is now called greater Israel.
As is pointed out by Schlomo Sands and others, during the purported exodus in 72AD the majority of Jews did not leave Israel but many converted to Christianity and later to Islam. The spread of Judaism through the Roman empire and beyond during the early part of the first millenium AD was more the result of conversion than by the movement of people out of Israel.
Most of the land that now makes up Israel was taken by the Jewish forces in 1948 after the Palestinians, who owned over 90% of the land, were prevented from returning to their villages and their land after the war. Israel still has not compensated these people for the confiscation of their homes and property.